Best Cocktail Shaker Comparison Buying Guide (2017): Stir Things Up and Enjoy

Do you dream of being like Tom Cruise in Cocktail when you host a party, but the best you can do is bust out the blender and pina colada mix? Well, I’m about to stir things up and make that dream a reality (minus the Hawaiian shirt) with our top cocktail shaker guide.

best cocktail shaker buying guide

Making cocktails at home is easier than you think. Forget the fancy turns, flips and spins (Tom likes to show off), all you need is the right set-up: quality liquor, ice, some fruit juices and a premium shaker that brings them all together.

The right shaker can help you whip up Bloody Mary’s for brunches, kamikaze’s for Sunday football, and anything else you and your friends thirst for, quickly and easily. My guide will help you with it all, giving you a rundown of the top shakers, along with an in-depth look at the different types, uses and features.

The only thing I can’t teach you are all those fancy moves..at least not yet. Stay tuned- I’m working on it.

Cocktail Shaker Basics

To get things started, let me explain what a cocktail shaker is and what its purpose is. Cocktail shakers are 2 or 3-piece device used to mix and blend various drinks by shaking. The device consists of a long tin or metal cup with a metal top or glass to cover it; in some cases, there is a built-in strainer.

You combine different ingredients, usually juice, ice and liquor in the cup, then cover and shake. Shaking allows everything to mix well, and lets the ice cool and slightly dilute the mixture, for an expertly blended drink that is smooth and refreshing.

Shakers bring variety to your home bar, making the process uncomplicated and entertaining. They ensure you can give your guests whatever they want and also make sure drinks are mixed correctly. They also allow you to be daring and try new flavors or styles of drinks, expanding your palette and knowledge.

Top Cocktail Shaker Comparison

There are a lot of excellent cocktail shakers on the market at affordable prices, so it really comes down to what works best for you. Each of these top picks have different features to offer, so there is something here for everyone.

Cocktail Shaker Set by SILVERgrade


This Cobbler style shaker set is the perfect companion to any home bartender, taking them from beginner to pro in no time. Priced at just $18, the set has a tin shaker and built-in strainer, along with 2 pour spouts, 2 jiggers and a cocktail book to help you truly entertain your guests and teach you the ropes.

The entire set is made of stainless steel, so it won’t rust or break, for easy care and maintenance. The main tin is 24-ounces, so you can concoct multiple drinks at once, and the recipe book lets you come up with unique and refreshing drinks.

The 2 jiggers allow you to perfectly measure liquor before adding it to the tin, which is a big help when making complicated and layered drinks. Meanwhile, the 2 pourers let you pour shots and more like a pro-Tom Cruise move over! Finally, the strainer is built into the cap, so you can shake and pour martini’s and look good while doing it.

A good teaching shaker if you want to regale your guests and elevate your cocktail style.

Barware Styles® Classic and Elegant Stainless Steel 3-Piece Martini and Cocktail Shaker Set



Check Price on Amazon
This set is easily the best value for your money, with a price tag just under $15. Consisting of 3-pieces and a free jigger for precise pouring, this set is low in price but high in quality.

Designed with high-grade stainless steel, it won’t rust or leak for a mess-free experience. Plus, the high-grade steel means no metal taste when mixing, for fresh, appetizing drinks every time.

The tin is 24-ounces, so you can mix for you and your closest friends without hassle and there is an eBook included that has over 50 drink recipes. Dishwasher safe and free of any chemicals, this is a smart investment that gives you your money’s worth.

Mixologist World Cocktail Shaker Set


For those who already know the basics, or like to host large parties, this set is a bargain under $20. With a shaker, jigger, cocktail book, mocktail book and eBooks, you can make sure very guest is happy and refreshed.

Constructed of BPA-free, superior stainless-steel, the 3-piece tin shaker set is adept at mixing classic and exotic drinks. The elimination of chemical treatments means pure flavors, giving this set versatility.

It works well with tequila, vodka, whiskey, gin, rum and any other premium liquor. It also is great for making mocktails (non-alcoholic drinks), so you can serve elegant beverages to those who can’t or don’t enjoy alcohol.

The shaker is 24-ounces, so it can hold 3 drinks at once and is protected against rust, leaks and erosion. Comes with a 5-year warranty and is a great for social butterflies who love to entertain.

Cocktail Shaker Set – Professional Bartender Kit in a Luxury Bag



Check Price on Amazon

If you want something that you can use at home or away, this set fits the bill thanks to a plush carry bag and sturdy construction.

You get a complete bar-on-the go, as this set has a 3-piece Cobbler shaker, double jigger, 2 pourers and recipe book that fits neatly in a luxurious bag. So you can mix drinks at home or shake up some cocktails for friends on the beach.

The tin shaker is BPA-free and comes with a lifetime warranty, so you are guaranteed to be getting a quality product. Constructed with high-grade steel, the shaker and cap/strainer are dishwasher safe and won’t stain or leak when in use.

The 2 pourers give you control when pouring measurements or shots and the double jigger takes the guesswork out of how much you poured. And the book of 100 recipes means you can try a new drink at every party.

A great travel or home set that will last for years to come.

Innovee Cocktail Shaker Premium Bar Set


Check Price on Amazon

Looking for style and function? If so, then check out this eye-catching shaker set from Inovee. Designed to impress with a shiny stainless-steel finish, you’ll be even more impressed by the $15 price tag and how well-made it is made.

This 24-ounce shaker looks polished and professional, and would impress a professional thanks to the fine strainer and solid fit between the shaker and the top.

You can flip and shake without it opening or spilling, so you can dazzle not just with the taste of your drinks, but with your moves as well. Plus, the free jigger is great to serve shots or calculate servings.

Dishwasher safe, you will never see any tarnish or erosion, looking just as shiny as the day you bought it. With a recipe book to help you create original and classic drinks, this is a set that works in any home.

Cocktail Shaker Varieties

While all cocktail shakers have the same basic style and purpose, there are some differences in terms of materials used and how the pieces fit together. To help you figure out what type suits you best, here is an overview of the different types, along with the pros and cons of each.

Boston Shaker

These are the most commonly used shakers, and a favorite among bartenders, consisting of a tin and glass cup. You can add ingredients to the glass, to see how much you are using of each, then place the tin on top, which lays neatly inside the glass.

Flip it over, shake, and voila: you have the perfect drink. This style has a lot of great advantages, as they are both inexpensive and easy to clean. However, it takes a little practice to fit the parts together, there is no strainer and the glass can break, so beginners will want to go slowly.

Cobbler

The Cobbler is sleek and easy to use, with a tin shaker, cap and built-in strainer for 1-2-3 mixing of just about any ingredient. Available in stores everywhere, it is quite convenient thanks to the all-in-one design and various sizes available.

You can get a single-drink size shaker for more intimate gatherings or a larger one that mixes 10-15 drinks at a time, saving you time when you have big parties. Plus, you can add ice, ingredients, shake and pour: no other tools needed.

On the down side, the built-in strainer means you need to clean between drinks if you are making different cocktails and the metal on metal can make it hard to open at times. Also, the holes to pour are smaller than average, which can slow down serving times. Best used for smaller parties.

French/Parisian

The French, or Parisian style shaker looks similar to the Boston style, only it is sleeker and more polished thanks to the tin upper part in place of glass. Considered to be the original and a classic among bartenders, it is easily the most stylish and looks great on top of any bar.

This design has no strainer, but is easier to open than the Boston, so mixing is quick and hassle-free. The only negative is that it is hard to find, so you’ll most likely need to buy one online.

Cocktail Recipes

For those of you just starting out, or anyone looking to try something new, here are a few recipes for your next party:

3 cocktail recipes

Cosmopolitan

This cocktail is classic and timeless, making it a favorite and must-know recipe for any bartender.

Ingredients
  • 1-ounce Vodka (citrus flavored if you prefer)
  • ¼ ounce triple sec
  • 1 ½ ounces of cranberry juice
  • ½ ounce fresh lime juice
  • 1 cup of ice
Shake vodka, triple sec, cranberry juice and lime juice over ice in a cocktail shaker with strainer. Pour into a large cocktail glass and garnish with a lime if desired.

Mai Tai

This is a slight variation of the original recipe, eliminating difficult-to-find ingredients without sacrificing taste.

Ingredients
  • 2 ounces 10 Cane Rum, or 1 ounce of 10 Cane and 1 ounce of Captain Morgan
  • ¾ ounce of orange curacao
  • ¾ ounce lime juice, fresh
  • ¼ ounce orgeat syrup
  • Lime wedge and 2 sprigs of mint for garnish

Fill a cocktail shaker 1/3 of the way with ice, then add all the ingredients and shake well. Strain into an old fashioned filled with ice and garnish with mint springs and lime wedge if desired.

Margarita

There are many versions of this party favorite, so here is a basic one you can serve as is or add to to make it your own.

Ingredients
  • 2 ounces of tequila
  • 1ounce lime juice, freshly squeezed
  • ½ ounce triple sec
  • Lime wedge as garnish
  • Salt to rim glass

Rim the edge of a margarita glass with salt. Fill cocktail shaker 2/3 with ice, then add all the liquid ingredients and shake 10-15 seconds. Place ice in margarita glass and strain contents of shaker into the glass over the ice. Garnish with lime wedge if desired. To upgrade to a more sophisticated margarita, use a premium tequila like Patron Silver or replace triple sec with Grand Marnier.

Now that you armed with all you need to know about cocktail shakers, it’s time to buy one and get rid of that blender for good. My top cocktail shaker guide proves that anytime can be a great home bartender with the right tool- and a quality cocktail shaker is just that tool.

Inexpensive, stylish and fun, they make creating and serving cocktails a breeze. They are easy to care for and even simpler to use: all you need to do is learn a few recipes (and copy some of Tom’s moves and your set).

So what are you waiting for? If you want to say good-bye to your blender for real and stir up something new and fresh, go out and get a cocktail shaker today.